Welcome to Rosie the Reviewer, a Dutch-Canadian female-led WW2 media podcast. A new episode airs every Friday!

Ep 104 – Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man – One War Too Many

Subscribe:

Apple PodcastsCastBoxPocketCastsSpotifyRSSAmazon MusicYouTube

Support the podcast

Rosie the Reviewer is a passion project, built episode by episode. If you’d like to support what we do, you can help keep us on the air or pick up some Rosie merch. We’re working on more ways for you to get involved in the future.

Description

This week on Rosie the Reviewer, we talk about Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man (2026), directed by Tom Harper and written by Steven Knight. The film serves as the finale of the Peaky Blinders TV series (2013-2022) and is set during World War II, following an ageing Tommy Shelby as he navigates Nazi counterfeit schemes, the Birmingham Blitz, and a son he barely knows. We get into the writing choices that don’t land, the female characters who deserved better, the real history of Operation Bernhard and the Birmingham Blitz, and what made the original series work, and why this film loses it.

Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man trailer

Historical context for Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man

The Real Peaky Blinders

The Peaky Blinders were a real Birmingham street gang whose heyday was the 1890s, not the 1920s as the TV series depicts. They emerged from the slums of Small Heath and Bordesley during the Industrial Revolution, when economic inequality and overcrowding bred organised crime across British cities. The gang’s name almost certainly comes from Birmingham slang “peaky” for a peaked flat cap, “blinder” meaning something dapper or striking. By the early 1900s, police crackdowns had eroded their power and rival criminal networks had moved in.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaky_Blinders

Operation Bernhard

Operation Bernhard was a Nazi scheme to destabilise the British economy by flooding it with forged banknotes. The original plan, to airdrop counterfeit currency over Britain, was abandoned as unworkable, and by 1942 the operation had pivoted to using the forged notes to finance German intelligence operations. Around 140 Jewish prisoners at the Sachsenhausen concentration camp, selected for their backgrounds in printing, engraving, and finance, were forced to study and replicate British banknotes. The operation was named after its SS overseer, Major Bernhard Krüger. At peak production, the prisoners were manufacturing approximately one million notes per month across denominations from £5 to £50. The Bank of England responded by withdrawing all notes above £5 from circulation in 1943; the £10 note was not reintroduced until 1964. Total forgeries are estimated at somewhere between £132 million and £300 million. The counterfeiters narrowly survived the war when an execution order came down in the final weeks, but bureaucratic delays in assembling all the prisoners narrowly saved them. Remaining forged notes, with a face value of £9 million, were found at the bottom of an Austrian lake after the war.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Bernhard

John Beckett

John Beckett was a real person: a former Labour MP who represented Gateshead and then Peckham in the 1920s before moving sharply to the right. He joined Oswald Mosley’s British Union of Fascists in 1934, rising to Director of Publications before his falling-out with Mosley led to his dismissal in 1937. That same year, he co-founded the National Socialist League with William Joyce, later known as Lord Haw-Haw, before leaving to establish the British People’s Party in 1939. His son, journalist Francis Beckett, has written critically of the film’s portrayal of his father as a one-dimensional villain, arguing that lazy historical mythmaking does a disservice to understanding how fascism actually operates. Beckett was imprisoned under Defence Regulation 18B in May 1940 after MI5 uncovered detailed plans he had drawn up for a collaborationist government in the event of German invasion.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Beckett_(politician)

The Birmingham Blitz

Birmingham was the third most heavily bombed British city of the war, after London and Liverpool. As a major centre of armaments production, building Spitfires, tanks, and munitions, it was a strategic target. The Luftwaffe carried out 77 air raids on the city between 1940 and 1943, killing 2,241 people, seriously injuring over 3,000 more, and leaving tens of thousands homeless. The BSA factory in Small Heath, which Steven Knight’s mother worked at, was directly hit on the night of 19 November 1940. Fifty-three workers were killed when two bombs collapsed the building on top of them. The opening cards of the film acknowledge the attack and dedicate it to their memory.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birmingham_Blitz

Roma People in Britain During World War II

An estimated 45,000 Roma were living in Britain at the start of World War II. Though they faced less systematic persecution than Roma in occupied Europe, they were a marginalised community with limited access to literacy and institutional support. Despite this, Roma men and women contributed to the British war effort, serving in the military, auxiliary services, and war production industries, including factories, forestry, and agriculture. Maartje highlights the case of Eric Stanley Lock, a decorated RAF fighter pilot (DFC, Bar to DFC, and DSO) who was the highest-scoring British ace of the Battle of Britain. He went missing over Pas-de-Calais on 3 August 1941 and was never found. A claim that Lock was of Romani heritage comes from the Encyclopaedia of the Nazi Genocide of the Sinti and Roma in Europe, but this cannot currently be verified from mainstream biographical records.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Lock

Other episodes mentioned

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More episodes

Ep 96 – I Was Monty’s Double – M. E. Clifton James’ Role of A Lifetime

In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, we discuss I Was Monty’s Double (1958), a British WWII film based on M.E. Clifton James’ memoir. The film tells the almost unbelievable story of an actor recruited to impersonate Field Marshal Bernard Montgomery in the lead-up to D-Day, as part of a wider Allied deception effort. Clifton James plays himself, and Monty. How any of this was true, we don’t know, because it really is stranger than fiction.

Go to episode »

Ep 66 – The Imitation Game – Alan Turing, Oscar Bait and the Spy Subplot No One Asked For

In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, we take on The Imitation Game (2014) and unpick all the ways it does Alan Turing dirty. With guest George (our usual SAS Rogue Heroes correspondent) taking on several sidequests with us this summer), we tackle the unnecessary spy plot, the myth of the lone genius, and why turning one of history’s most brilliant minds into a socially inept robot is just lazy, disrespectful writing. Sam did all the reading, Maartje Googled for one minute and George has actually been to Bletchley Park. All of us instantly agree: this movie is not it.

We talk queer erasure, posthumous pardons, codebreaking accuracy (or lack thereof), and Sam explains EXACTLY how Turing’s codebreaking machine works ;).

This movie is Oscar bait biopic mayhem (it worked, I guess), and we have some strong thoughts.

Go to episode »
Rosie the Reviewer A Bridge Too Far

Ep 81 – A Bridge Too Far – Operation Market Garden Discussed at Length

In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, we take on Richard Attenborough’s A Bridge Too Far (1977), the war epic based on Cornelius Ryan’s book of the same name about Operation Market Garden. We take you through one of WWII’s most ambitious (and doomed-to-fail) military plans as we discuss the film. From Sean Connery’s Major General Urquhart to Gene Hackman’s Sosabowski (we approve), we talk about what led to Market Garden’s failure, and how Dutch civilians like Kate ter Horst were astoundingly brave in the face of absolute hell.

Market Garden, a little complicated? We try to make it simple for you!

Go to episode »
Hemingway & Gellhorn

Ep 73 – Hemingway & Gellhorn – Who is the Better War Correspondent?

This week on Rosie the Reviewer, we’re diving into the 2012 HBO film Hemingway & Gellhorn. It’s all about the messy relationship between war reporter Martha Gellhorn and Ernest Hemingway. We get into the Spanish Civil War (and yes, the movie really drags its feet before getting to WWII), and honestly, we’re not sure either of them is all that likable. Plus, we talk about Caroline Moorehead’s biography Gellhorn: A Twentieth-Century Life, Martha’s own novel Point of No Return, and her travel memoir, Travels with Myself and Another.

Go to episode »

Ep 69 – Masters of the Air – Tuskegee Airmen, POW Marches and Closing Thoughts (Part Three)

In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, we’re wrapping up our three-part journey through Masters of the Air with a look at episodes 7-9.  We’re once again joined by George! From the marches out of Stalag Luft III to Rosie Rosenthal’s decision to fly more missions and Croz sleeping through D-Day. We get into the show’s depiction of the Tuskegee Airmen and see where everybody ends up. Safe flight, Masters!

Go to episode »

Support the podcast

Rosie the Reviewer is a passion project, built episode by episode. If you’d like to support what we do, you can help keep us on the air or pick up some Rosie merch. We’re working on more ways for you to get involved in the future.