Description
In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, we discuss The Thin Red Line (1998), directed by Terrence Malick and based on James Jones’s semi-autobiographical novel of the same name. This might be the most philosophical anti-war film ever made. We discuss Guadalcanal as paradise, and the antagonist: the war as a whole. Not even the Americans are heroes in this one. The most heroic thing they did? Leave.
The Thin Red Line trailer
The Thin Red Line Historical Context
Guadalcanal and the Pacific War, 1942–1943
Guadalcanal, in the Solomon Islands, was the site of the first major Allied offensive against Imperial Japan. American forces landed in August 1942 to seize a strategically vital airfield the Japanese were constructing. What followed was a six-month campaign of brutal fighting on land, sea, and in the air. Guadalcanal was not a decisive victory in isolation; it was the beginning of the long island-hopping campaign that would eventually bring American forces within striking distance of Japan.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guadalcanal_campaign
James Jones and the Battle of Mount Austen
James Jones served with the 25th Infantry Division on Guadalcanal and took part in the fighting around Mount Austen, a high, heavily fortified ridge that forms the basis for the fictional Hill 210 in the novel and film. Jones was wounded during fighting on Guadalcanal when he re-injured an ankle, which eventually led to his medical discharge from the army. He drew directly on this experience when writing The Thin Red Line (1962).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Jones_(author)
The Strategic Importance of Henderson Field
The airfield that American forces seized at the start of the Guadalcanal campaign (renamed Henderson Field after Marine aviator Major Lofton Henderson, killed at Midway) was the strategic heart of the operation. Control of it determined air supremacy over the surrounding waters, which in turn controlled the naval supply lines for both sides
Other episodes mentioned
Ep 86 – Bruce McKenna on The Pacific, Band of Brothers, and the stories he’d like to tell.
In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, we welcome an extraordinary guest: Bruce McKenna, co-executive producer, creator, and principal writer of The Pacific, and writer of the Bastogne episode of Band of Brothers. We talk about the moral stakes of war, what made it into the episodes and what didn’t, and why everything is about narrative and theme.
We explore Bruce’s creative process and the kind of stories he likes to tell. This one may change how you look at WWII media.
Ep 77 – The Pacific – Closing Out the Best War Show of All Time (Part Three)
In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, we wrap up our three-part discussion of The Pacific (2010) with episodes 7-10. Brace yourself for the brutal fighting on Peleliu and Okinawa to John and Lena Basilone, his final chapter and the long road home for Eugene Sledge and Robert Leckie. Alongside our returning guest George, we talk about leadership, disillusionment, the role of civilians, and the way grief and memory follow these men long after the war ends.
Ep 76 – The Pacific – Episodes 4-6 the Battle of Peleliu and More (Part Two)
Joining us to discuss episodes 4-6 of The Pacific (2010) is our friend Merc. We get into the meaty middle part of the show, saying hello to some new favourites (and clinging to them before they have to leave us again) while watching others go home. Its’ Peleliu time, which means everyone is having a terrible time. And Pavuvu, which is apparently not much better.
Ep 75 – The Pacific – Discussing Episodes 1-3 and a Lot of Bob Leckie (Part One)
In this episode of Rosie the Reviewer, Bec returns to the pod to talk about the first three episodes of our favourite HBO War drama The Pacific (2010). Together, we discuss the show’s opening, the amazing theme, the great friendships… and we can’t stop gushing about Bob Leckie. Sorry. Not really.
Ep 30 – The Pacific Special with Actor Scott Gibson – Behind the Scenes of HBO’s The Pacific
For the video version of this podcast, please go to our Youtube channel: www.youtube.com/@rosiethereviewer
This week, we have a very special guest on the pod: actor Scott Gibson. We talk to him about his portrayal of Andy Haldane in HBO’s The Pacific, his recent trip to Guam and Peleliu with Beyond the Call and his upcoming documentary.
Ep 16 – Life Is Beautiful – A Heartfelt Journey Through Tragedy and Comedy
Buongiorno Principessa! In this episode, we laugh and we cry about this magical and tragical Italian masterpiece. Is it just us, or do hilariously funny films make the best tragedies?
Book Rec by Sam
The Thin Red Line by James Jones
